You are now ready to go on a vacation: you have booked a ticket, you have purchased a decent carry-on bag, and you have planned all the activities that you are going to do on your destination. However, you are suddenly reminded of your last cruise and seasickness; you shudder on the memories of the nightmarish nausea and dizziness. Don’t worry! This time, make sure that you bring some drugs that can help with motion sickness. Two extremely popular medications for motion sickness right now are Dramamine and Bonine. Which one is better? Below, we will see the comparisons between Dramamine vs Bonine to help you choose.
Overview: What are Antiemetic drugs?
Both Dramamine and Bonine are classified as antiemetic drugs. So, what is actually an antiemetic drug? An antiemetic drug is usually prescribed to reduce nausea and vomiting, which may be resulted by various factors such as the side effects of other drugs (including the drugs used as anesthetics during surgeries and the ones for chemotherapy), infections, or motion sickness.
An antiemetic drug works by interfering with the neurotransmitter receptors (cells that receive and send nerve impulses) that are involved in nausea and vomiting. However, the neural pathways that control such bodily reactions are very complex. The type of the antiemetic drug to use depends on the case.
The antiemetic drugs used to treat motion sickness, such as Dramamine vs Bonine, are mostly antihistamines. These antihistamines can prevent nausea and vomiting by keeping the inners parts of the ears from fully sensing motion.
Dramamine is available in several different products. One of them contains ginger, which enhances the taste and helps to warm the body. There is also a special formula that is designed for kids. The original formula in each tablet contains 50 mg of dimenhydrinate, which may interact with alcohol, medicines that make you feeling sleepy, some medicines for cold, cough, or allergies, and MAOIs such as Eldepryl, Marplan, Carbex, Nardil, and Parnate. It does not contain any artificial sweetener.
On the other hand, Bonine is only available in one product, so there is no confusion on which product to buy. The active ingredient in each tablet is 25 mg meclizine hydrochloride, which may interact with a variety of drugs for treating insomnia, anxiety, psychotic disorders, allergies, and muscle spasms. It contains some artificial sweetener.
Dosage and Consumption
When choosing between Dramamine vs Bonine, know that these two medications have differences in how they are consumed. The differences include whether to swallow or to chew, the dosage, and the age suitability. Both Dramamine and Bonine require you to take the dosage at least one hour before engaging in the activity that causes motion sickness.
The original formula of Dramamine is designed for children as well as adults. It provides dosing instructions for children as young as 2 years old. So, if you are looking for a child-friendly motion sickness drug, this product is a viable option.
Dramamine is great for long trips because it allows you to take one or two tablets every four to six hours. So, if you are going on a long trip that involves more than one flight, you can take a dose of Dramamine prior to your first flight and take another dose later once the effects have worn off. It is swallowed with the aid of some water.
On the other hand, Bonine is not designed for children. It only provides dosing instructions for people older than 12 years old. Do not give it to young children, as the dosage would be too high. Bonine is consumed by chewing – the artificial sweetener it contains is there to improve the taste of the drug. Hence, this drug can be your choice if you have difficulties swallowing tablets.
Bonine can be taken one or two tablets at once. If you are an adult with severe motion sickness, you may need to take the two-tablet dosage. However, this product only allows you to take one dosage per day. The effects last for several hours, but not for the entire day.
Both Dramamine and Bonine are very effective for preventing motion sickness. They are best for preventing motion sickness, rather than medicating the problem, which means that you should take the dosage before traveling instead of waiting until the symptoms kick off.
The effects of Dramamine seem to wear off a little bit more quickly, but you can take another dosage after four to six hours if you still need to continue the trip. On the other hand, Bonine seems to lasts a little bit longer, but it does not last for the whole day and it cannot be taken more than once in a day.
Dramamine is also sometimes used to treat Meniere’s Disease, which is an inner ear condition. On the other hand, Bonine is quite commonly used to reduce the symptoms of vertigo, which is a condition that disrupts your body’s balance and causes you to feel as if the room is spinning.
Finally, the factor that you need to consider when choosing between Dramamine vs Bonine is how much drowsiness that you can tolerate. Such motion sickness drugs often make you drowsy and sleepy. When the effects kick in, you may want to just sleep for the entire duration.
Dramamine causes more drowsiness. It really makes you drowsy. With this drug, you will want to just sleep and rest. Hence, it is only suitable if the trip does not have any interesting thing.
Bonine causes much less drowsiness. It indeed makes you a little bit sleepy, but not as much as Dramamine. Hence, this is a great choice if you don’t want to spend the duration of the trip by sleeping, for example when going on a cruise.
Both Dramamine and Bonine are effective for preventing motion sickness. Dramamine can be your choice if you are very prone to motion sickness and you have a long trip ahead of you. It can be taken once every four to six hours. However, it makes you very drowsy. On the other hand, Bonine can be your choice if you don’t want to get too drowsy on your trip. Bonine allows you to stay awake, and can last a little bit longer. But Bonine can only be taken once a day.